Don\'t pay her Terry. For $1,500 I would definitely go to court and make her prove that you are legally liable for the mirrors, which will be difficult. I\'m no lawyer, but I get the sense that it may be impossible to prove the mirrors were broken during the time period in which you were responsible for the building. She may not even bother going to court and will just try to work something out with you on the side. Tell her she\'s gonna have to take it to court and there\'s a good chance she\'ll never bother. The lack of police reports will totally work against her as the plaintiff. I don\'t know much, but I feel like the odds are against her bothering to go to court, and if she really did the odds are even further against her winning. You\'ve got outs here Terry. The worst that could possibly come of it is that the court makes you pay for new mirrors, which you were about to sign yourself up for anyhow just because she told you to.
Can I call the biggest shennanigans of all time and say that it was in fact the dance lady who did it? She waited until there was a night event at the UAC, then sent someone to break the mirrors so she could get new ones. (And tried to extort way too much money for their replacement out of the liable parties.) Just a thought.