You guys are nuts, this is going to expose many new people to the band. Also it\'s not like Tim, Chris, & Adrian will get worse during this time period, they can still write new material and debut new songs with Stoops in the picture. Enjoy your heteraide.
Do you think all these new fans are going to stick around when they go back to being a 3 piece after 1/1?
No, it\'ll be cool for the shows he plays but then we are back to square one.
This band has not made any ground in the last 12-18 months.
Besides, I don\'t think they can survive as a band without Stoops.
What makes you so sure that the new fans wont stick around? You think zero faces will be owned, zero new hardcore fans will be gained? Also you seem pretty sure that Stoops will be out like a fat girl playin dodgeball 1/1. Source?
Don\'t be naive. The first run through as a 3 piece BARELY held together. I enjoyed it but the shows were extremely light.
What makes you think they will stay?
I am saying the opposite of that Stoops is leaving. I think he is staying.
Spacey I respectfully disagree on lesser points...
The Breakfast does not *need* a keyboard player. Ooops, brain fart. The Breakfast needs a keyboard player!
To me Breakfast Trio was not their highest point musically. The high points being pretty much any time with Sequoia or Matt in the picture. Tim is in my top 5 favorite all time musicians so I hate to criticize at all -- but I really hope not to see the guy trying to tackle keyboards and guitar at the same time again. I mean its badass that he could pull it off... but IMO it caused a lot of limitations that you don\'t have with a seperate guy on keys.
What are we disagreeing with?
I believe the Breakfast needs a Keyboardist to survive.