being a firm audience recordings over soundboard guy, i\'d say that the aud\'s out there are much better than an ambience-less soundboard mixed for the room not listening. there\'s no depth, no excitement to sbd\'s. and again, whoever\'s amps/vocal mics don\'t push enough will be the overwhelmingly loudest part of any soundboard. especially since they\'re still playing places where they don\'t all have to go through the pa in the first place. and do you really want to try to spread a show where the vocals are the most prominent?? no offense to the band, vox have gotten much better, but still....
of course, all that said, it seems like most younger folks (ie, ideal new fan candidates) like sbd\'s because they don\'t know how/have the equipment to truly listen to an audience recording, so maybe its not that bad an idea....
it hurt to type that.