Should each song have its own thread?

• Should each song have its own thread?
  Posted by davepeck on 04 Aug, 2006 14:38
• paul\'s DMB thread gave me an idea..
  
  instead of having the lyrics section as it is now (just one thread with every song), what about a new Song Forum, with one thread for each song? the first post will have the lyrics, and each thread can have discussion about song meanings, interpretations, best versions, etc...
  
  what\'s everyone think? vote.
• 
  
• #1 Reply
  Posted by FreeSpirit on 04 Aug, 2006 14:42
• sounds great... but complicated.  just like ur poll.  why is there no "maybe" choice???!!! :confused:
• 
  
• #2 Reply
  Posted by Me! on 04 Aug, 2006 14:43
• I say WTF why not it might create a few quiet threads but a few that will be pretty busy too, but I see no reason as to why not......
• 
  
• #3 Reply
  Posted by Todd on 04 Aug, 2006 14:44
• What\'s so complicating? Yes or no. There\'s no maybes here!!!
• 
  
• #4 Reply
  Posted by davepeck on 04 Aug, 2006 14:45
• Quote from: FreeSpirit

  sounds great... but complicated.  just like ur poll.  why is there no "maybe" choice???!!! :confused:

  
  sorry, i forgot there would be women voting too.. :duck:
• 
  
• #5 Reply
  Posted by FrankZappa on 04 Aug, 2006 14:47
• sounds like a good idea. A Breakfast version of The Annotated Grateful Dead Lyrics
  
  Another idea might be to periodically update the first post as well. Once there is an agreeded upon theme, that could be posted up top as an official/unofficial statement on what the song is about. That way (especially for newbies) they wont have to read through the whole thread to find out what the agreed upon definition is.
• 
  
• #6 Reply
  Posted by Me! on 04 Aug, 2006 14:55
• I think that\'s enough votes so get on it Dave, sheesh fuckin slacker
• 
  
• #7 Reply
  Posted by FreeSpirit on 04 Aug, 2006 15:07
• Quote from: Todd

  What\'s so complicating? Yes or no. There\'s no maybes here!!!

  hhmmph... that\'s very unethical and discriminatory for this so-called "open-minded board."  I refuse to be a part of such an evil conspiracy where there are no "maybes" ...  
• 
  
• #8 Reply
  Posted by weekapaug19 on 04 Aug, 2006 15:07
• I was actually thinking that when I saw the DMB thread...go for it!!
• 
  
• #9 Reply
  Posted by Mamalakabubadaya on 04 Aug, 2006 15:08
• you guys are such **** geeks.
• 
  
• #10 Reply
  Posted by Todd on 04 Aug, 2006 15:41
• Quote from: davepeck

  Quote from: FreeSpirit

  sounds great... but complicated.  just like ur poll.  why is there no "maybe" choice???!!! :confused:

  
  sorry, i forgot there would be women voting too.. :duck:

  rotfl
• 
  
• #11 Reply
  Posted by FrankZappa on 04 Aug, 2006 15:56
• Quote from: Todd

  Quote from: davepeck

  Quote from: FreeSpirit

  sounds great... but complicated.  just like ur poll.  why is there no "maybe" choice???!!! :confused:

  
  sorry, i forgot there would be women voting too.. :duck:

  rotfl

  
  well, enjoy sleeping on the couch todd.
• 
  
• #12 Reply
  Posted by SlimPickens on 04 Aug, 2006 19:36
• Quote from: FrankZappa

  sounds like a good idea. A Breakfast version of The Annotated Grateful Dead Lyrics
  

  With the kind of foolishness that gets posted on this board (me being a contributor of said nonsense), I think its a bit of a pipe dream to think these threads will at all resemble The Annotated GD page.
  
  But I still think its a good idea.
• 
  
• #13 Reply
  Posted by FrankZappa on 04 Aug, 2006 20:41
• well thats why I suggested updating the first post, so that you can read that for the good info, or go through the whole thing if you want to.
• 
  
• #14 Reply
  Posted by DocEllis70 on 05 Aug, 2006 00:04
• i vote yes.  Dave, that means your original lyrics to the Chase, or excuse me, \'Count Funkula\' may eventually surface now!
•