im still sticking with rift...in my opinion it has a more halloween feel to it, it is a very mysterious album with very spooky tracks. Plus there are more songs on it, and (besides reba) better overall writing in composed parts of the songs than on lawn boy. Hearing the breakfast play maze would be insane...it would be a great way to showcase matt\'s talents on organ, and tim would rip on the solo. It\'s Ice is one of my top 3 favorite phish songs, and it would be incredible to hear them play it...although parts of it are very tricky to play (im sure they would have no problem with some practice. Not to mention Rift, MOUND, the wedge!, finishing with the horse>SITM, it would be the most complete, best overall album to cover, EVERY song on there is quality (haha lenthwise would be halarious).
The song I would most want to hear on Lawnboy would be SOAM, no question. Actually now that I look at lawnboy, the songs on there allow for more jamming than the songs on rift. Yeah I guess either one would be sweet.